Side-by-side comparison

Sherwin-Williams Scuff Tuff Interior Waterbased Enamel Flat Extra White vs Behr Premium Plus Interior Flat Medium Base

Sherwin-Williams Scuff Tuff Interior Waterbased Enamel canSherwin-WilliamsScuff Tuff Interior Waterbased EnamelFlat · Extra White48PoorReplace
Behr Premium Plus Interior canBehrPremium Plus InteriorFlat · Medium Base80ExcellentReplace
Documented facts for both products
FactScuff Tuff Interior Waterbased EnamelPremium Plus Interior
UseInterior paintInterior paint
Sheen · baseFlat · Extra WhiteFlat · Medium Base
VOC (untinted)30 g/L1 g/L
VOC added by tintNot statedNot stated
Emissions testingTested (LEED emissions)Tested (GREENGUARD)
Health certificationNone foundNone found
Safety Data Sheet warnings21
Ingredient disclosurePartial (environmental data sheet)Full list (Health Product Declaration)
Safety Data Sheet revised8/30/20263/3/2026

Highlighted rows are where the two products differ. Facts come from each maker's documents; "not disclosed" means the maker hasn't published it, not that the product failed a test.

See the score broken down by category
Free. Answer 4 quick questions and create your account.

Compare another

Scores summarize the evidence makers publish. They don't guarantee safety or predict individual health outcomes. How we score

Sources